Bella News
When a student withdraws from or is terminated by a beauty school, it’s crucial to perform a refund calculation in compliance with NACCAS (National Accrediting Commission of Career Arts and Sciences) guidelines. Failing to handle this correctly can lead to serious legal and financial repercussions for school owners, including audits, fines, and even jail time.
This blog post will walk you through the entire process of conducting a proper refund calculation, how to ensure compliance with accreditation requirements, and why this step is non-negotiable for school owners. Follow along, and you'll understand why documentation is key and how to protect your school from potential pitfalls.
Why Refund Calculations Are Crucial for School Owners
Many school owners may not realize the importance of performing refund calculations whenever a student withdraws or is terminated. Here's why it's critical:
Legal Compliance: If a student withdraws and there's a discrepancy between the amount of tuition paid and what the student owes, the school must issue a refund for any excess funds received from the government or the student. Failure to do so can result in serious legal consequences, including fines or even jail time.
Accreditation Requirements: Schools accredited by NACCAS must follow strict guidelines regarding refund calculations. Not doing so can lead to a school losing its accreditation, impacting future enrollment and financial aid opportunities.
Protecting the School’s Reputation: Ensuring that refunds are handled properly prevents complaints from students claiming the school is withholding their money. Complaints can harm a school’s reputation and even result in legal actions.
The Fundamentals of NACCAS Refund Calculations
When a student leaves, whether through withdrawal or termination, a refund calculation must be performed every time, regardless of whether the school owes the student money or the student owes the school. Ignorance of this rule is no excuse, and schools cannot skip this step—even if no money is owed on either side.
Step-by-Step Guide to Conducting a Refund Calculation
1. Collect the Basic Information
Student Name, Address, and Phone Number: Start by gathering the personal information of the student.
Course: Indicate the program the student was enrolled in (e.g., cosmetology, esthetics).
Start Date: Record the student's official start date.
Hours Clocked: These are the actual hours the student physically attended school.
Last Date Attended: Record the last date the student was physically present.
2. Input the Contracted Hours
Total Program Hours: Each program has a total number of contracted hours. For example, a cosmetology program may require 1,500 hours, while an esthetics program may only require 750 hours. Input the contracted hours for the program in which the student was enrolled.
3. Determine Scheduled and Actual Hours
The next step involves calculating the hours the student was scheduled to attend versus the actual hours they were present.
Scheduled Hours: If a student was supposed to attend 40 hours per week and withdrew after one month, they would have had 160 scheduled hours (40 hours per week multiplied by 4 weeks).
Actual Hours: Compare the scheduled hours to the actual hours the student attended. For example, if they only attended 120 of the 160 scheduled hours, input that number.
4. Calculate the Program Elapsed Percentage
To determine how much of the program the student has completed, divide the actual hours attended by the total number of contracted hours. For instance, if a student was contracted for 1,500 hours but only completed 168 hours, the percentage would be calculated as 168 ÷ 1,500 = 0.112, or 11.2%.
5. Find the Earned Tuition Percentage
Now, use the NACCAS refund chart to determine the percentage of tuition the school is entitled to keep. This is based on the percentage of the program the student has completed. For example, if the student completed 11% of the program, the school is typically entitled to keep 40% of the total tuition.
6. Calculate the Earned Tuition
Multiply the total tuition by the percentage of tuition earned. For instance, if the total tuition is $11,200 and the school is entitled to 40%, the school has earned $4,480.
7. Add Fees
Include any non-refundable fees like registration fees, kit fees, or other charges that were disclosed upfront. These fees must be added to the earned tuition before calculating any refund.
8. Compare Payments and Calculate Refund (or Amount Owed)
Amount Paid to the School: Review how much the student or the government has already paid.
Amount Earned by the School: Compare this with the amount the school has earned, based on the calculation.
If the amount paid exceeds the amount earned, the school owes the student a refund. If the amount earned is greater, the student owes the school.
9. Document the Process
Once the calculation is complete, document everything meticulously. Print out the refund calculation, make copies of checks (if applicable), and have the student sign a receipt of any refund issued. This documentation should be stored in the student's file for future reference.
What Happens If a Student Owes Money?
Sometimes, after performing the refund calculation, it becomes clear that the student owes the school money. Even in these cases, the refund calculation must still be documented, showing that the school is entitled to additional funds. Whether or not the school will be able to collect those funds is another matter, but the documentation is crucial.
The Dangers of Skipping Refund Calculations
Failure to complete refund calculations correctly can lead to significant problems:
Audit Risks: Schools that don’t properly document refund calculations may face audits from NACCAS or other regulatory bodies. An audit can delay or prevent a school’s accreditation renewal.
Legal Repercussions: Schools that do not refund excess money to students can face legal challenges. In extreme cases, school owners may even face criminal charges for fraud if federal funds are misused.
Loss of Financial Aid Eligibility: Schools that don’t comply with refund calculation requirements risk losing access to federal financial aid, which can severely impact enrollment.
Automating Refund Calculations
Many school management systems, such as Genesis, Fame, or Discovery Pro, offer automated tools to help with refund calculations. These systems can save significant time and effort, reducing the chances of human error. However, if your school doesn’t have the budget for these systems, manual calculations are still entirely possible—just follow the steps outlined above.
The Importance of Documentation
"Documentation beats conversation," as the saying goes. In the world of education, particularly in handling refunds, this couldn't be truer. Even if no money changes hands, you must complete a refund calculation and document that no money is owed. This protects your school from complaints and ensures you remain in compliance with NACCAS regulations.
Conclusion
Handling student withdrawals and terminations is a delicate process that must be managed properly to avoid legal and financial pitfalls. By consistently performing and documenting refund calculations, you protect your school, comply with NACCAS requirements, and ensure a transparent and fair process for both your institution and the students.
When in doubt, always refer back to the refund calculation worksheet and ensure that all steps are followed. If you're unsure, don’t hesitate to seek help from professionals or invest in software that can automate the process for you.
Important Takeaways:
Always perform a refund calculation, no matter the circumstance.
Document every transaction and calculation thoroughly.
Use scheduled hours, not actual hours, to determine the refund.
Automate the process if possible, but manual calculations are still effective if done correctly.
Final Thought: Staying compliant with NACCAS refund policies is not only the ethical thing to do—it’s a legal requirement that can save your school from severe consequences. Take the time to get it right, every time.